Monday, November 28, 2011

A Different Sky by Meira Chand

Title: A Different Sky
Author: Meira Chand

Genre: Fiction (Historical / WWII / 1930s / Singapore / Cross-Cultural Romance / Racism / Colonialism / Post-Colonial Fiction / War)
Publisher/Publication Date: Random House UK (7/4/2011)
Source: The publisher.

Rating: Liked.
Did I finish?: I did -- took some time, but it was worth it!
One-sentence summary: A detailed look at life in Singapore, from the late 1920s through the 1940s, through the viewpoints of three very different Singaporeans.
Reading Challenges: Historical Fiction, South Asian

Do I like the cover?: Eh -- it's okay. I would have preferred a black and white photo of Singapore, perhaps, something that better represented the place of the story rather than one of the characters.

I'm reminded of...: Nevil Shute

First line: On the journey they spoke about the island, a pinprick on the great body of Asia.

Buy, Borrow, or Avoid?: Borrow -- but immediately start reading because you'll need some time to dig in!

Why did I get this book?: I never say no to historical fiction and I was intrigued by the WWII setting.

Review: This is the kind of historical fiction that educates, effortlessly. Set in Singapore, spanning 1927 through 1946, this novel was a unique read for me in that it covered an era I love in a setting wholly unfamiliar to me. Chand's characters aren't royalty or society elite but every day people caught up in a changing landscape; real historical moments meet the every day.

Chand's focus in this novel is on three primary groups in Singapore: the Eurasians -- Howard Burns, his mother, and his sister, local citizens of indigenous and European descent, viewed by the white Europeans as only a step above 'natives'; the transplanted Indians -- Raj Sherma, who migrated to Singapore for economic independence and ends up embroiled with the Japanese by a twist of fate; and the Chinese -- Mei Lan, a smart young woman whose family straddles modern European ideas and traditional Chinese culture and is caught, herself, between accepting her family's wishes and starting off on her own.

In almost any novel, the lives of women interest me most, so I was unsurprised to find that Mei Lan's story grabbed me immediately. However, Chand's detailed plotting, character development, and nuanced study of race, class, and education sucked me and I ended up caring deeply for both Raj and Howard as well. Even though I think the jacket blurb tries to imply a love triangle, this isn't just a historical romance set up in an exotic locale. This is really a novel about Singapore and the occupation of the land, first by the British and then by the Japanese. Identity and alliance is intrinsic to the story. Howard's mother, Rose, perceives the European disdain for Eurasions to be right and appropriate while Howard chafes at the implication. Raj struggles to rectify his experiences with the Japanese -- every one he's met has mentored and educated him -- with the virulent anti-Japanese sentiment in Singapore. Both Howard and Raj are captivated by Gandhi's anti-colonial revolutionary actions in India, but are split as to whether Singapore should take up the movement. Mei Lan is desirous of the university education her brother is given, but feels committed to her Chinese identity especially when news of Japanese brutalities in China reach Singapore.

Like Nevil Shute's A Town Like Alice, this book covers the before, during, and after of occupation, and I appreciated Chand's ability to offer the spectrum of emotional responses. My only complaint is that despite the novel's length (483 pages), some moments felt thin and underdeveloped. Enormous events are skipped over, casually alluded to, and years pass with only a vague comment. The dips in and out of the lives of the secondary characters was both enjoyable and maddening: I loved the additional facets through which the story was told but I was frustrated by the lack of development and resolution with them, as they were as compelling as the leads.

This was my first Meira Chand novel but I'm absolutely going to look for the rest of her books: this was a meaty, engrossing, sink-your-teeth-into historical novel that will stay with me. I'm haunted by the characters and I wish I could follow them another twenty years.

*** *** ***


I'm thrilled to offer my gently used copy of A Different Sky to one lucky reader! To enter, fill out this brief form. Open to US/CA readers (international readers, if you're willing to split the shipping, I'd be happy to send to you if you win!) Ends 12/16.


  1. This sounds like it would be a really interesting read for me, and I am sure that I could learn a lot from it. I am glad to hear that you had such success with it, but sorry that it was a little sparse in areas. It sounds like it might have been a tad uneven. Still, that doesn't stop me from wanting to read it!

  2. @Heather: If the characters were less compelling, maybe I wouldn't have minded -- but I really cared about even the secondary folks and wanted to know everything about their lives! This was a really delightful novel -- a satisfying brick of a book!

  3. The 483 pages makes me nervous, but it definitely sounds like an interesting read! I can't say I've ever read a novel based in Singapore.

  4. @Meg: It is kind of a commitment -- this isn't a zippy read. But I enjoyed it for the depth -- I felt there without drowning in details nor flailing without direction.

  5. This sounds like an interesting and ambitious book. I know little about Singapore particularly during this time period. It sounds like Chand does a very good job of showing the impact on the people of the occupation by the British and the Japanese.
    Based on everything going on in this book and 3 different characters, the book sounds rather short!
    I'm glad you enjoyed it for the most part. Thank you for a terrific review!

  6. It sounds like a really good book. I would love to read it.

  7. I really can't stand the cover because it makes it look like some light read. BUT it sounds really interesting, and as others have mentioned, I haven't read anything of Singapore. Thanks for the giveaway!

  8. This book is one that not only I would enjoy reading, but that Anna would enjoy as well. I love books set during WWII time period in Asia.

  9. I love the setting as well. My WWII reading is almost always Europe-centred, which is a shame.

  10. I'm so glad you enjoyed this story as I have it on hold at my library, where they haven't purchased it yet so it may be months. I liked A Town Like Alice very much but I enjoyed the first part which dealt with the prison camp and war much more than the later bits, oddly enough. I look forward to reading A Different Sky now, thank you.

  11. @Sandra: Then you're esp going to enjoy this book -- it focuses a great deal on the occupation (which was my least favorite part of A Town Like Alice! ;))

  12. Thanks for sharing your copy! I think I'd LOVE this book - the time period and setting are favorites of mine!