Beneath the Shadows by Sara Foster

Title: Beneath the Shadows
Author: Sara Foster

Genre: Fiction (Contemporary / Yorkshire / Missing Person / New Mother / Isolation / Gothic )
Publisher/Publication Date: Minotaur Books
Source: NetGalley

Rating: Okay.
Did I finish?: I did.
One-sentence summary: Grace returns to Yorkshire a year after her husband's disappearance in hopes of finding answers.
Reading Challenges: A-to-Z, E-book, NetGalley

Do I like the cover?: Oh, I do, I do -- how creepy is it? Pretty much that's the opening scene, too!

I'm reminded of...: Rosamund Lupton, Jennifer McMahon

First line: They should be home.

Buy, Borrow, or Avoid?: Borrow for a wintry thriller!

Why did I get this book?: I love gothic-y novels set in Yorkshire!

Review: For an innocuous thriller, this book provoked a lot of emotion in me, and gave me much to chew over in terms of my expectations of a book, a heroine, and a story. The premise of this book is simple: Grace, new mom, has moved to rural Yorkshire with her husband and their three-month old daughter. One wintry evening, she comes home to a note from her husband, saying he has something to tell her. She waits, and waits, and later finds her daughter in the pram outside of their cottage, husband gone.

He never returns.

A year later, Grace returns to the cottage to try to put it in order and decide what to do. Husband still missing, she's unable to sell the cottage, and she's scared at the future she faces. Does she move on? Hold out hope? The police suggest her husband simply abandoned them but Grace is reluctant to accept that in light of what she feels is the evidence of his happiness with them. Complicating matters is the ghostly nature of the Yorkshire moors, her odd neighbors,

Sounds pretty fascinating, right? The thing with stories like this, however, is that the heroine really needs to be able to carry the weight of a story. When the entire focus is on her -- her thoughts, her fears, her apprehensions, her decisions -- she's got to be pretty compelling to keep the story interesting and for me, Grace was just okay. Foster's writing is lovely -- I certainly 'felt' the moors and the poky cottage and the weird neighbors -- but I found Grace a bit bland. We're told she's compelling and interesting -- she and her husband had a glittering life in London, her best mate has been in love with her, the new handyman clearly has the hots for her -- and yet, I didn't see much evidence of Grace's magnetism. Foster certainly showed me a woman wracked with insecurity, frozen with fear, made passive by the looming unknown of her future, and all that resonated.

The pacing of this book is slow, which was maddening at times but also delightfully stressful (in a good way). Foster hints at other gothic-y dramas in this story -- Grace reads Rebecca and thinks of the handyman as a kind of Heathcliff -- and the mood and ambiance is one of waiting, agonized waiting. At one point, I was surprised to discover I was halfway through the book because it still all felt like build up to the real story, the point where Grace would start investigating her husband's disappearance, and instead, all we got was her unpacking boxes, dealing with her flashy sister, and running into the handsome handyman. By the time we got to the ah-ha! reveal, I was relieved to know, but it came a little to late in the story for my tastes.

Still, this was a promising novel that had ambiance in spades and I'll be keeping an eye out for Foster's other novels -- this was a creepy armchair escape.


  1. Oh my, this does sounds creepy! Thanks for the review, I might check this one out when I'm ready to get chills :)!

    1. Totally perfect for the winter, too -- it's so chilly in feel!!

  2. Hmmm. This is one I have from NetGalley, that expires eventually.. and maybe I'll just let it expire. It's actually a chore to read any eBook on my old pandigital, so if I am frustrated and impatient with it that is not going to be good.
    We'll see.

    1. I love my ereader but I did miss being able to just page ahead -- somehow clicking ahead just doesn't feel the same way!

  3. It does sound delightfully creepy, but not sure I want to read it, given what you say about the bland heroine and her taking forever to learn about her husband's disappearance.

    1. The heroine might click for you -- I liked her at the start but she just got tiresome after a while. Her sister was more vibrant, the handyman more moody, the wacky neighbors more wacky...but she felt bland. And in some way, that made sense -- she was kind of dead inside and really in a waiting place -- but that's not compelling storytelling, being with someone numb and boring, so...yeah.

  4. I just saw another review of this book today- what a coincidence :-) I enjoy mysteries, but for some reason I prefer them in a historical setting to a contemporary one. I also like ones that have the same detective growing over the course of the series. So not sure if this one would be very successful for me, either.

    1. Yes -- I love historical mysteries and find literary thrillers a little too much for me -- either too gory, too tense, or too...unsatisfying. Still, this had great mood!

  5. What a chilling sounding book! It sounds like there's a lot of tension and suspense here.

    (Has this cover been recycled, by the way? It looks familiar.)

    1. Yeah, the cover looks v familiar to me too but I'm not sure from where. I thought originally it was that it resembled The Replacement by B Yovanoff but in googling that, it's not really the same (other than having a pram). If you can recall the cover it resembles, I would be grateful -- it's 'on the tip of my tongue!' ;)

  6. I really want this one. I'm going to have to remember the next time I'm at the store. Thanks!

  7. Excellent review! I've been really enjoying mysteries and thrillers lately and this one sounds intriguing. Knowing its flaws, however, I won't be rushing to read this one, but I will probably end up reading it sometime this summer when the heat is making me crazy and I need to get away to winter.

  8. This sounds creepy and I love the cover as well. On the list it goes:) thanks


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Goldilocks by Laura Lam

The Overstory by Richard Powers

Weekend reads, or quaran-weekend