Monday, January 27, 2014

Anvil of God by J. Boyce Gleason

Title: Anvil of God
Author: J. Boyce Gleason

Genre: Fiction (Historical / 8th Century / France / Northern Europe / Court Intrigue / Sibling Relationships / Historical Figures Fictionalized / Medieval Christianity / Paganism)
Publisher/Publication Date: iUniverse (7/26/13)
Source: Historical Fiction Virtual Book Tours

Rating: Loved.
Did I finish?: Yes, I inhaled this one!
One-sentence summary: In 8th century Europe, four heirs battle each other for freedom, power, and happiness after the death of their powerful patriarch.
Reading Challenges: Historical Fiction

Do I like the cover?: I'm on the fence. At moments, I really like it, and at others, I feel like it gives the novel a Dan Brown-y feel (which it isn't!).

I'm reminded of...: Marion Zimmer Bradley

First line: "God's will be done," Carloman whispered as the forward line closed on the enemy.

Buy, Borrow, or Avoid?: Borrow or buy!

Why did I get this book?: Saw so many great reviews of it, I wanted in on the excitement!

Review: On the surface, this isn't precisely the kind of historical fiction I'm drawn to, a medieval tale of fathers and sons, conflict and war, a kingdom divided. But after seeing one rave review after another for this one, I jumped on the chance to review it, and I'm so glad I did.

Opening in 741, the novel follows Charles Martel (grandfather to Charlemagne) in his last days. Dividing his kingdom among his three sons Carloman, Pippin, and Gripho, Charles thinks to quell rebellion and infighting. Instead, pious Carloman chafes that the more pagan-minded Gripho has land, while Pippin is preoccupied with his mistress. Charles' daughter, Hiltrude, grew up indulged by her father to the point that she trained with a sword while wearing Saracen armor, but despite her wishes, is betrothed to a foreign prince to shore up his loyalty. Upon his death, Charles' plans are for naught as his children strike out on their own, and the resulting conflict has enormous implication.

This novel reads with the rich, lurid, dramatic, and soap opera-ish intensity of Marion Zimmer Bradley and Philippa Gregory. In addition to the battle between siblings, there is a war of religion, and Gleason's use of pagan spirituality is what lead to my Bradley comparison (although this is a decidedly non-magical novel). I'm not one for detailed descriptions of battle, especially in a book filled with battles, but Gleason marvelously described the events without making it a blur of weapons and tools and gore.

At 405 pages, this is a beast, but despite its size, the novel raced. Gleason's characters were distinct and huge with personality while the plot was, well, plotty! Shifting between the brothers and Hiltrude, Gleason kept hold of his story while stoking drama and tension. (There is a slight whiff of an anachronistic heroine in Hiltrude, the sword-fighting noblewoman, but I have to admit, I so liked how he handled her, her father's indulgence of her, and how she behaved through the novel that I didn't mind she danced the line between historical and wholly fictional.)

I have to admit I did give a small eye roll when I saw this is the first in a trilogy. Before starting, I thought surely there would be no more story to tell -- but I was wrong. Nothing dragged nor felt extraneous in this book, and when I got to the book's end, I could have easily dove into another 400 pages just to remain with everyone.

There are nice extras to help the reader -- a small map, a family tree, and chart detailing which noble belongs to which locale. Gleason's Author's Note is 9 pages long and footnoted, and covers the plot line, characters, and places in the book.

Although this is the first in a trilogy, I very much found it a stand alone novel as most everything is resolved (to a point), so one can walk away satisfied or, like me, be impatient for the next book. Fans of medieval fiction will absolutely want to get this one as well as those who enjoy the court/royal setting.

*** *** ***


I'm thrilled to offer a hardcover copy of Anvil of God to one lucky reader! To enter, fill out this brief form. Open to US readers only, ends 2/14.


  1. I am glad it did not dragged, it's so easy for it sometimes

    1. Agreed -- and sometimes books this size need to be trimmed -- but in this case, every word/scene felt necessary!

  2. This sounds interesting Perhahps a little like the Game of Thrones? Regardless - I love complex stories with lots of characters so I'll give it a try - Thanks Audra.

    1. Judith, I contemplated the comparison, but haven't not read the GoT books, was hesitant. However, it sounds like it would be v similar to this book -- and if you like complex and personed, this is absolutely one for you!

  3. I give an eye roll at all trilogies. Must *everything* be a trilogy nowadays? Apparently so. But this seems like the kind of historical novel that's up my alley. I love that opening line!!

    1. Oh, I'm with you -- I am SO over the trilogy -- but I'm less resentful now because I kind of want another 800 pages with these people!

      You'd love the opening scene, frankly. It's a book written with readers like you in mind!

  4. Similarly I'm not so keen on the trilogy idea but the book itself, and that you say it could be a stand alone is very appealing. I probably wouldn't have picked it up for the summary and cover (I feel the same as you about wars in books) but your review has me very interested.

    1. This is one of those books that really benefits from the word of mouth thing, as I would never have given it a look from blurb alone. But so many diverse readers adored it, I just had to see what the big deal was -- and the raves are well-earned. It was a rich, surprising, gripping historical novel.

  5. It's always a sign of a good book for me when I finish and don't feel the story is incomplete, but still want to read more :)

    1. YES -- I love that feeling. It's like that meme I keep seeing, having a 'book hangover' -- I'm still stuck in Gleason's world.

  6. Only $3.49 in the Kobo store! I couldn't resist. :)