Friday, February 21, 2014

Under the Wide and Starry Sky by Nancy Horan

Title: Under the Wide and Starry Sky
Author: Nancy Horan

Genre: Fiction (Historical / 19th Century / Europe / American Ex-Pat / Artist / Robert Louis Stevenson / Bohemians / Marriage / South Pacific / Writing)
Publisher/Publication Date: Ballantine Books (1/21/2014)
Source: TLC Book Tours

Rating: Liked.
Did I finish?: I did!
One-sentence summary: The story of the American woman who would win the love of Scottish writer, Robert Louis Stevenson.
Reading Challenges: Historical Fiction, What's In a Name

Do I like the cover?: Love the cover -- so striking!

I'm reminded of...: Melanie Benjamin, Lynn Cullen

First line: "Where are the dogs?" Sammy asked, staring up at her.

Buy, Borrow, or Avoid?: Borrow or buy.

Why did I get this book?: I'd heard nothing but good things about Horan's previous novel.

Review: I'd long been interested in Nancy Horan having heard nothing but raves for her first novel, Loving Frank, and I'd been long eying this book.

Opening in 1875, the novel follows American Fanny van de Grift Osbourne, who has left California with her three children after realizing her husband wasn't going to give up his mistresses. A beloved nanny, heartbroken at their departure, paid her own passage to join them, and Fanny and company move first to Belgium, then France, so Fanny and her daughter Belle can pursue an art education.

After devastating tragedy, Fanny meets a Scottish writer, Robert Louis Stevenson, ten years who junior, who is immediately smitten with her. Their love affair turns into marriage, a life of Bohemian artists and authors, exotic travel, petty squabbles and great passion.  I'm being vague because there's no point in recounting the details; clocking in at 496 pages, this beefy chunkser does the heavy lifting.

Horan's novel represents what I most love about biographical historical fiction: fascinating people made real, their decisions and choices explored and imagined, given emotion. I was immediately charmed by the ambitious Louis, as Stevenson preferred to be called, but felt most for Fanny. Being a woman with ambition in the 19th century was no easy thing, and though she found a kind of freedom in Europe after leaving her philandering husband, once she became Louis' wife she had other obligations that squelched her dreams.

Horan articulates both Fanny and Louis with tender warmth, so even when they behaved badly, I still cared for them. While the pacing of the book occasionally felt slow to me, I was gripped by their story. Horan's use of historical details was effortless, and her narrative had hints of the philosophical to it, which I adored. I've read nothing set in 19th century South Pacific, so the sections in Samoa were fascinating -- those who enjoy armchair travel will want this book!

Rich, dense, emotional, and stirring, Horan's novel is a meaty exploration of marriage, creative endeavors, and the price of partnership. Those who love novels about the unknown women behind great men will want this one, as well as anyone who's suffered through (or enjoyed!) studying Stevenson in school. Strongly recommended.

*** *** ***


I'm thrilled to offer a copy of Under the Wide and Starry Sky to one lucky reader! To enter, fill out this brief form. Open to US readers only, ends 3/7.


  1. I loved Loving Frank so I'm glad to see this book getting great reviews like yours. I can't wait to read it.

  2. I too have heard good things about her other book- this one looks good!

    1. She's absolutely worth the praise -- I can't wait to read Loving Frank.

  3. I was so entranced by Loving Frank that I went to tour all his homes (available to see) in Oak Park, IL. I would love to read this story of Robert Louis Stevenson and his 'woman', especially as you liked the novel, too. Thanks for the opportunity to win!

    1. Oh, that's awesome! I love traveling after reading about places -- honestly, hist fic is my favorite kind of travel 'research'!

  4. This is the kind of book I LOVE - a great story about one of my favorite authors!

    Thanks for being on the tour Audra.

  5. I love the cover of this one...and its a book about an author...what's not to love.

  6. I read this and agree this is a good book if you want to know about the woman behind the writer. But I expected to learn about the woman behind the writer. Instead, we get half a book about the woman before she even met the writer, which bored the heck out of me.

    I wasn't happy with this book.

  7. Oh I can't wait to read this book, have heard so many good things about it.

    Nice review (thank you for no spoilers either :)

  8. Hallo Audra!

    I kept meaning to enter the contest, but time swept me away, and I simply haven't had the proper chance to drop back! This is one book I attempted to read for review but was always just shy of being at the right place/time to do so! I cannot wait to read it from my library, as it seriously captivated my attention ever since I first saw it offered through First Impressions via Book Browse!! Oh, my dear stars, this is one book I am itching to read for sure! I'll drop back and give you my thoughts & lamentations!!

    I tipped my hat for the bookaway, but again, I am not sure if I was in time!